Evaluation of Scoring and Weighting Methods for Soil Characteristics to Determine Soil Quality in Different Land Uses

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD Student, Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Guilan, Iran

2 Associated Professor, Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Guilan, Iran

3 Assistant Professor, Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Guilan, Iran

4 MSc, General Office of Natural Resources and Watershed Management of Guilan province, Rasht, Iran

10.22092/ijsr.2024.361794.700

Abstract

Forests have important role for ecosystem maintenance, and deforestation is one of the factors in degradation of soil quality.  In this study, using multivariate analysis, soil quality index was evaluated in three land uses including forest, grassland, and cropland at two depths of 0-10 and 10-20 cm in Sidasht of Guilan Province, Iran. The weighted additive soil quality was calculated using two methods: (1) Minimum data set (MDS1) and (2) Revised minimum data set (MDS2). Also, each feature’s variance and communality and two scoring methods, namely, linear and non-linear, were compared and evaluated. In MDS2, the effects of land use on soil quality index (SQI) indicated that the mean values calculated by the non-linear scoring method was significantly more precise than the linear one. Soil quality indices in forest and grassland had the maximum values when compared to cropland. SQIW2-MDS2-NLS had the highest sensitivity index (SI= 3.14). In MDS2, the soil properties including silt, Mean Weight Diameter, pH, CaCO3 and available phosphorus were selected. Efficiency ratio of MDS2 was 80% and in soil quality assessment, MDS2 had higher efficiency than MDS1. Soil condition and change of soil management practices were reflected in MDS2 more clearly than in MDS1. Accordingly, SQIW2-MDS2-NLS method was the best means for evaluating the effects of deforestation on soil quality in the studied area.

Keywords

References

  1. Amoakwah, E., M.A. Rahman, K.A. Nketia, R. Djouaka, N.O. Didenko, and K.R. Islam. 2021. Impact of deforestation and subsequent land-use change on soil quality. Eurasian Journal of Soil Science 10(2): 150-160.
  2. Armenise, E., M.A. Redmile-Gordon, A.M. Stellacci, A. Ciccarese, and P. Rubino. 2013. Developing a soil quality index to compare soil fitness for agricultural use under different managements in the Mediterranean environment. Soil and Tillage Research 130: 91-98.
  3. Askari, M.S. and N.M. Holden. 2015. Quantitative soil quality indexing of temperate arable management systems. Soil and Tillage Research 150: 57-67.
  4. Ayoubi, S., and S. Moazzeni Dehaghani. 2020. Identifying impacts of land use change on soil redistribution at different slope positions using magnetic susceptibility. Arabian Journal of Geosciences 13: 1-11.
  5. Bakhshandeh, E., M. Hossieni, M. Zeraatpisheh, andR. Francaviglia. 2019. Land use change effects on soil quality and biological fertility: a case study in northern Iran. European Journal of Soil Biology 95: 103119.
  6. Blake, G.R., and K.H. Hartge. 1986. Bulk density. Methods of soil analysis: Part 1 Physical and mineralogical methods 5: 363-375.
  7. Bremner, J.M. 1960. Determination of nitrogen in soil by the Kjeldahl method. The Journal of Agricultural Science 55(1): 11-33.
  8. Chandel, S., M.S. Hadda, and A.K. Mahal. 2018. Soil quality assessment through minimum data set under different land uses of Submontane Punjab. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis 49(6): 658-674.
  9. Chen, Y.D., H.Y. Wang, J.M. Zhou, L. Xing, B.S. Zhu, Y.C. Zhao, and X.Q. Chen. 2013. Minimum data set for assessing soil quality in farmland of northeast China. Pedosphere 23(5): 564-576.
  10. Davari, M., L. Gholami, K. Nabiollahi, M. Homaee, and H.J. Jafari. 2020. Deforestation and cultivation of sparse forest impacts on soil quality (case study: West Iran, Baneh). Soil and Tillage Research 198: 104504.‏
  11. Dengiz, O. 2020. Soil quality index for paddy fields based on standard scoring functions and weight allocation method. Archives of Agronomy and Soil Science 66(3): 301-315.
  12. Doran, J.W., and T.B. Parkin. 1994. Defining and assessing soil quality. Defining soil quality for a sustainable environment 35: 1-21.
  13. Dou, Y., Y. Yang, S. An, and Z. Zhu. 2020. Effects of different vegetation restoration measures on soil aggregate stability and erodibility on the Loess Plateau, China. Catena 185: 104294.
  14. Duan, L., H. Sheng, H. Yuan, Q. Zhou, and Z. Li. 2021. Land use conversion and lithology impacts soil aggregate stability in subtropical China. Geoderma 389: 114953.
  15. Fathizad, H., M.A.H. Ardakani, B. Heung, H. Sodaiezadeh, A. Rahmani, A. Fathabadi, T. Scholten, and Taghizadeh-Mehrjardi R. 2020. Spatio-temporal dynamic of soil quality in the central Iranian desert modeled with machine learning and digital soil assessment techniques. Ecological Indicators 118: 106736.
  16. Gee, G.W., J.W. Bauder, and A. Klute. 1986. Methods of soil analysis, part 1, physical and mineralogical methods. Soil Science Society of America Book Series. American Society of Agronomy, Inc. and Soil Science Society of America, Inc. Madison, Wisconsin, 404-410.
  17. Govaerts, B., K.D. Sayre, and J. Deckers. 2006. A minimum data set for soil quality assessment of wheat and maize cropping in the highlands of Mexico. Soil and tillage research 87(2): 163-174.
  18. Huang, W., M. Zong, Z. Fan, Y. Feng, S. Li, C. Duan, and H. Li. 2021. Determining the impacts of deforestation and corn cultivation on soil quality in tropical acidic red soils using a soil quality index. Ecological Indicators 125: 107580.
  19. Karlen, D.L., C.A. Ditzler, and S.S. Andrews. 2003. Soil quality: why and how? Geoderma 114(3-4): 145-156.
  20. Kemper, W.D., and R.C. Rosenau.1986. Aggregate stability and size distribution.
  21. Liu, M., G. Han, Z. Li, Q. Zhang, and Z. Song. 2019. Soil organic carbon sequestration in soil aggregates in the karst Critical Zone Observatory, Southwest China. Plant, Soil and Environment 65(5): 253-259.
  22. Liu, M., G. Han, Z. Li, T. Liu, X. Yang, Y. Wu, and Z. Song. 2017. Effects of slope position and land use on the stability of aggregate-associated organic carbon in calcareous soils. Acta Geochimica 36(3): 456-461.
  23. Mamehpour, N., S. Rezapour, and N. Ghaemian. 2021. Quantitative assessment of soil quality indices for urban croplands in a calcareous semi-arid ecosystem. Geoderma 382: 114781.
  24. Marzaioli, R., R. d’Ascoli, R.A. De Pascale, and F.A. Rutigliano. 2010. Soil quality in a Mediterranean area of Southern Italy as related to different land use types. Applied Soil Ecology 44(3): 205-212.
  25. Nabiollahi, K., F. Golmohamadi, R. Taghizadeh-Mehrjardi, R. Kerry, and M. Davari. 2018a. Assessing the effects of slope gradient and land use change on soil quality degradation through digital mapping of soil quality indices and soil loss rate. Geoderma, 318, 16-28.
  26. Nabiollahi, K., R. Taghizadeh-Mehrjardi, and S. Eskandari. 2018b. Assessing and monitoring the soil quality of forested and agricultural areas using soil-quality indices and digital soil-mapping in a semi-arid environment. Archives of Agronomy and soil science 64(5): 696-707.
  27. Nabiollahi, K., R. Taghizadeh-Mehrjardi, R. Kerry, and S. Moradian. 2017. Assessment of soil quality indices for salt-affected agricultural land in Kurdistan Province, Iran. Ecological indicators 83: 482-494.
  28. Olsen, S.R., C.V. Cole, F.S. Watanable and L.A. Dean. 1954. Estimation of available phosphorus in soils by extraction with sodium bicarbonate; United States Department of Agriculture: Washington, D. C., USDA Circular 939.
  29. Qi, Y., J.L. Darilek, B. Huang, Y. Zhao, W. Sun, and Z. Gu. 2009. Evaluating soil quality indices in an agricultural region of Jiangsu Province, China. Geoderma 149(3-4): 325-334.‏
  30. Rahmanipour, F., R. Marzaioli, H.A. Bahrami, Z. Fereidouni, and S.R. Bandarabadi. 2014. Assessment of soil quality indices in agricultural lands of Qazvin Province, Iran. Ecological indicators 40: 19-26.
  31. Raiesi, F. 2017. A minimum data set and soil quality index to quantify the effect of land use conversion on soil quality and degradation in native rangelands of upland arid and semiarid regions. Ecological Indicators 75: 307-320.
  32. Raiesi, F. and V. Kabiri. 2016. Identification of soil quality indicators for assessing the effect of different tillage practices through a soil quality index in a semi-arid environment. Ecological Indicators 71: 198-207.
  33. Rezaee, L., A.A. Moosavi, N. Davatgar, and A.R. Sepaskhah. 2020. Soil quality indices of paddy soils in Guilan province of northern Iran: Spatial variability and their influential parameters. Ecological Indicators 117: 106566.
  34. Rezapour, S., and O. Alipour. 2017. Degradation of Mollisols quality after deforestation and cultivation on a transect with Mediterranean condition. Environmental Earth Sciences 76(22): 1-13.
  35. Rhoades, J.D. 1983. Soluble salts. In: A. L. Page (Eds.), Methods of Soil Analysis: Part 2. Chemical and Microbiological Properties ASA / SSSA, Madison, Wisconsin, USA, pp. 167-179.
  36. Santos-Francés, F., A. Martínez-Graña, C. Ávila-Zarza, M. Criado, and Y. Sánchez. 2019. Comparison of methods for evaluating soil quality of semiarid ecosystem and evaluation of the effects of physico-chemical properties and factor soil erodibility (Northern Plateau, Spain). Geoderma 354: 113872.
  37. Sione, S.M.J., M.G. Wilson, M. Lado, and A.P. González. 2017. Evaluation of soil degradation produced by rice crop systems in a Vertisol, using a soil quality index. Catena 150: 79-86.
  38. Selmy, S. A., A. Al-Aziz, H., Salah, R. Jiménez-Ballesta, F. Jesús García-Navarro, and M.E. Fadl. 2021. Soil Quality Assessment Using Multivariate Approaches: A Case Study of the Dakhla Oasis Arid Lands. Land 10(10): 1074.
  39. Sheidai Karkaj, E., A. Sepehry, H. Barani, J. Motamedi, and F. Shahbazi. 2019. Establishing a suitable soil quality index for semi-arid rangeland ecosystems in northwest of Iran. Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition 19(3): 648-658.
  40. Sparks, D.L., A.L. Page, P.A. Helmke, R.H. Leoppert, N.P. Soltanpour, M.A. Tabatabai, G.T. Johnston, and M.E. Summer. 1996. Methods of Soil Analysis, Soil Science Society of American Journal. Book Series No. 5.
  41. Tesfahunegn, G.B. 2014. Soil quality assessment strategies for evaluating soil degradation in Northern Ethiopia. Applied and Environmental Soil Science 2014.
  42. Tufa, M., A. Melese, and W. Tena. 2019. Effects of land use types on selected soil physical and chemical properties: the case of Kuyu District, Ethiopia. Eurasian Journal of Soil Science 8(2): 94-109.
  43. Vasu, D., S.K. Singh, S.K. Ray, V.P. Duraisami, P. Tiwary, P. Chandran, A.M. Nimkar, and G. Anantwar. 2016. Soil quality index (SQI) as a tool to evaluate crop productivity in semi-arid Deccan plateau, India. Geoderma 282: 70-79.
  44. Walkley, A., and I.A. Black. 1934. An examination of the Degtjareff method for determining soil organic matter, and a proposed modification of the chromic acid titration method. Soil science 37(1): 29-38.
  45. Walling, D.E., and B.W. Webb. 1980. The spatial dimension in the interpretation of stream solute behavior. Journal of Hydrology 47(1-2): 129-149.
  46. Yu, P., D. Han, S. Liu, X. Wen, Y. Huang, and H. Jia. 2018a. Soil quality assessment under different land uses in an alpine grassland. Catena 171: 280-287.
  47. Yu, P., S. Liu, L. Zhang, Q. Li, and D. Zhou. 2018b. Selecting the minimum data set and quantitative soil quality indexing of alkaline soils under different land uses in northeastern China. Science of the Total Environment 616: 564-571.
  48. Zaher, H., M. Sabir, H. Benjelloun, and H. Paul-Igor. 2020. Effect of forest land use change on carbohydrates, physical soil quality and carbon stocks in Moroccan cedar area. Journal of environmental management 254: 109544.
  49. Zeraatpisheh, M., E. Bakhshandeh, M. Hosseini, and S.M. Alavi. 2020. Assessing the effects of deforestation and intensive agriculture on the soil quality through digital soil mapping. Geoderma 363: 114139.
  50. Zhang, Y., X. Xu, Z. Li, C. Xu, and W. Luo. 2021. Improvements in soil quality with vegetation succession in subtropical China karst. Science of the Total Environment 775: 145876.
  51. Zhao, F.Z., L. Bai, J.Y. Wang, J. Deng, J.C. Ren, X.H. Han, G.H. Yang, and J. Wang 2019. Change in soil bacterial community during secondary succession depend on plant and soil characteristics. Catena 173: 246-252.
  52. Zhou, M., Y. Xiao, Y. Li, X. Zhang, G. Wang, J. Jin, G. Ding, and X. Liu. 2022. Soil quality index evaluation model in responses to six-year fertilization practices in Mollisols. Archives of Agronomy and Soil Science 68(2): 180-194.
  53. Zuber, S.M., G.D. Behnke, E.D. Nafziger, M.B. Villamil. 2017. Multivariate assessment of soil quality indicators for crop rotation and tillage in Illinois. Soil Tillage Research 174:147–155

 

Iranian Journal of Soil Research
Volume 37, Issue 4
March 2024
Pages 355-375

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics