ارزیابی تناسب بخشی از اراضی دشت مغان برای توسعه کشت آبی یونجه: رویکردی مقایسه‌ای بین روش‌های پارامتریک و الکتره ترای

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

مؤسسه تحقیقات خاک و آب، سازمان تحقیقات، آموزش و ترویج کشاورزی، کرج، ایران.

10.22092/ijsr.2026.373348.826

چکیده

با توجه به محدودیت و تغییر کاربری اراضی زراعی در دهه‌های گذشته، تعیین تناسب اراضی گامی حیاتی در جهت کشاورزی پایدار و حفظ محیط زیست است. این تحقیق با هدف ارزیابی تناسب 3930 هکتار از اراضی دشت مغان برای کشت یونجه تحت آبیاری بارانی، به مقایسه روش‌ پارامتریک ریشه دوم با روش چندمعیاره الکتره ترای پرداخته است. بدین منظور، داده‌های ۱۶0 خاک­رخ بررسی شد و ۸ ویژگی کلیدی شامل عمق خاک، آهک، گچ، pH، هدایت الکتریکی، درصد سدیم تبادلی، شیب و اقلیم از طریق تجزیه به مؤلفه‌های اصلی و سنجش چندبعدی گزینش شد. وزن معیارها با ماتریس مقایسه زوجی و آستانه‌های مدل الکتره ترای، بر اساس جدول نیازمندی‌های گیاهی تعیین شد. نتایج روش الکتره ترای بیشتر با واقعیت میدانی بر اساس عملکرد محصول، در واحدهای تحت کشت یونجه تطابق داشت. آزمون‌های چند متغیره هاتلینگ و ویلکس صحت تفکیک کلاس‌ها را در روش الکتره ترای تأیید کردند. همچنین آزمون LSD اختلاف معنی‌داری را میان ویژگی‌های خاک در کلاس‌های تناسب اراضی تفکیک ‌شده با این روش نشان داد. در نهایت، روش الکتره ترای به دلیل تعیین مناسب حدود انتقالی، اعمال آستانه‌های واقع­‌بینانه و بهره‌گیری از اصول منطق فازی، دقت بالاتری نسبت به روش‌ پارامتریک ریشه دوم در ارزیابی تناسب اراضی نشان داد.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله [English]

Land Suitability Evaluation in a Part of the Dasht-e-Moghan for Irrigated Alfalfa Cultivation Development: A Comparative Approach Between Parametric and ELECTRE-TRI Methods

نویسندگان [English]

  • Javad Seyedmohammadi
  • Mir Naser Navidi
Soil and Water Research Institute, Agricultural Research Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Karaj, Iran
چکیده [English]

Background and Objectives: Given the decline in agricultural land over the past decades, determining land suitability is a vital step toward sustainable agriculture and environmental preservation. Alfalfa is one of the most important forage crops in the world, playing a vital role in providing livestock feed and supporting the development of the livestock industry. This crop has a special place in crop rotation due to its high production potential, excellent nutritional value, and positive role in improving soil structure. However, to sustainably increase yield and prevent soil quality decline, it is essential to pay attention to optimal land management. Considering the strategic importance of alfalfa cultivation, the necessity of land suitability assessment studies for sustainable exploitation of soil resources, and the research gap in the study area in the field of applying advanced decision-making models, this study aims to determine the suitability of land units under sprinkler irrigation, identify susceptible and limiting areas, and finally, compare the efficiency of the multi-criteria ELECTRE TRI method and the parametric square root method in a part of the lands of the Moghan Plain.
 

 



Materials and Methods: The study area, with an area of 3930 ha, is a part of the Dasht-e-Moghan, which is located between 47°43′ to 47°50′ E longitude and 39°24′ to 39°28′ N latitude. The average annual temperature and rainfall of the region are 15.4 ℃ and 271.5 mm, respectively. The soil moisture regime was aridic bordering on xeric, and the soil temperature regime was thermic. For sampling, the study profiles were first gridded and surveyed at 500 m intervals. A total of 160 profiles were dug, and samples were taken from their different horizons. In total, 46 soil map units were separated at the regional level. To achieve the suitability of land units, eight key attributes, including soil depth, calcium carbonate, gypsum, pH, electrical conductivity, exchangeable sodium percentage, slope, and climate, were selected using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Euclidean distance. Criterion weights were determined via a pairwise comparison matrix, and the thresholds for the ELECTRE-TRI model were established based on the crop requirement table. Subsequently, the parametric square root method and the multi-criteria ELECTRE-TRI method were used for land suitability evaluation for alfalfa cultivation.
 
Results: The results of land suitability assessment showed that, based on the square root method, 11.61% of the land was classified in the S1 class, 63.5% in the S2 class, 24.36% in the S3 class, and 0.52% in the N1 class. On the other hand, the use of the ELECTRE TRI multi-criteria model for qualitative assessment of land suitability showed that 26.79% of the land was in the S1 class, 60.74% in the S2 class, 12.39% in the S3 class, and 0.08% in the N1 class. Slope, soil depth, electrical conductivity, and exchangeable sodium percentage are the most important characteristics limiting alfalfa growth in the region. The ELECTRE-TRI model results were more consistent with field reality based on crop yield in units under alfalfa cultivation. Hotelling's Trace and Wilks' Lambda multivariate tests confirmed the accuracy of class discrimination in the ELECTRE-TRI method. Furthermore, the LSD test revealed significant differences among soil properties across the land suitability classes differentiated by this approach. Ultimately, the ELECTRE-TRI method exhibited higher accuracy than the parametric square root method for land suitability evaluation due to its appropriate determination of transition boundaries, application of realistic thresholds, and use of fuzzy logic principles.
 

 



Conclusion: From a practical perspective, the output maps provide planners of the study area with an efficient decision-making tool for implementing smart and spot-based management of inputs, including local amendment of saline-sodic soils and monitoring of phosphorus dynamics. Moreover, by separating inappropriate lands, this approach prevents the waste of investment in the development of sprinkler irrigation systems in sensitive lands. In this regard, operators and executive experts of the region are advised to prioritize corrective measures such as adding manure fertilizers to improve the physical condition of the soil, optimal use of phosphate fertilizers, and the use of biological fertilizers in units facing limitations. Finally, exploring the potential of other modern multi-criteria decision-making models, measuring the dynamics of suitability boundaries under climate change scenarios, and integrating this methodology with machine learning algorithms to predict production potential on a large scale are among the most important research needs for future studies.

 

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Alfalfa
  • Dasht-e-Moghan
  • ELECTRE-TRI
  • Land suitability evaluation
  • Square root method
  1. AbdelRahman, M.A.E., Yossif, T.M.H. and Metwaly, M.M., 2025. Enhancing land suitability assessment through integration of AHP and GIS-based for efficient agricultural planning in arid regions. Scientific Reports, 15, 31370. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-14051-7.
  2. Akinci, H., Ozalp, A.Y. and Turgut, B., 2013. Agricultural land use suitability analysis using GIS and AHP technique. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 97, pp.71-82. https://doi.org/1016/j.compag.2013.07.006
  3. Akram, M., Batool, I. and Kahraman, C., 2026. An explainable hybrid fuzzy-machine learning framework for multi-crop suitability classification using agro-environmental data. Knowledge-Based Systems, 333, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.knosys.2025.115008
  4. Alemayehu, S., Ayana, E.K., Dile, Y.T., Demissie, T., Yimam, Y., Girvetz, E., Aynekulu, E., Solomon, D. and Worqlul, A.W., 2020. Evaluating Land Suitability and Potential Climate Change Impacts on Alfalfa (Medicago sativa) Production in Ethiopia. Atmosphere, 11(10), https://doi.org/10.3390/atmos11101124
  5. Bilal, H., Lahlou, F.Z. and Al-Ansari, T., 2025. Land suitability assessment and self-sufficiency evaluation for fodder crop production in a hyper arid environment coupling GIS-based multi-criteria decision making and optimization. Ecological Modelling, 501, 111021. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2025.111021.
  6. Dasheng, W., Xue, F. and QingQing, W., 2011. The research of evaluation for growth suitability of Carya Cathayensis Sarg. based on PCA and AHP. Procedia Engineering, 15, pp.1879-1883. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2011.08.350
  7. Davatgar, N., Neishabouri, M.R. and Sepaskhah, A.R., 2012. Delineation of site specific nutrient management zones for a paddy cultivated area based on soil fertility using fuzzy clustering. Geoderma, 173-174,111-118. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2011.12.005
  8. Ersado, A.E. and Talluri, V.K., 2026. GIS-based land suitability evaluation and multi-criteria decision analysis for sustainable enset (Ensete ventricosum (Welw.) Cheesman) cultivation in Hadiya Zone, Central Ethiopia. PLoS One, 21(3), https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0344127.
  9. Esfandiarpoor Borujeni, I., Mohammadi, J., Salehi, M.H., Toomanian, N. and Poch, R.M., 2010. Assessing geopedological soil mapping approach by statistical and geostatistical methods: A case study in the Borujen region, Central Iran. Catena, 82,1-14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.catena.2010.03.006
  10. , 1979. Soil Survey Investigations for Irrigation. FAO Soils Bulletin No. 42. FAO, Rome. 188p.
  11. , 2006. Crop Evapotranspiration (Guidelines for Computing Crop Water Requirements), FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper, No. 56, 333p.
  12. , 2012a. Crop Yield Response to Water. FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper No. 66, 519p.
  13. , 2012b. Global Agroecological Zones, Version 3, IIASA, Laxenburg, Austria and FAO, Rome, Italy, 196p.
  14. Fontana, M.E. and Cavalcante, C.A.V., 2013. ELECTRE TRI method used to storage location assignment into categories. Pesquisa Operacional, 33(2),283-303. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0101-74382013000200009
  15. Ghorbani, M. (2013). The Economic Geology of Iran: Mineral Deposits and Natural Resources. Springer Science and Business Media. 572p. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-5625-0
  16. Kazemi,, Sadeghi, S. and Akinci, H., 2016. Developing a land evaluation model for faba bean cultivation using geographic information system and multi-criteria analysis (A case study: Gonbad-Kavous region, Iran). Ecological Indicators, 63, pp.37-47. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2015.11.021
  17. Mendas, A. and Delali, A., 2012. Integration of multicriteria decision analysis in GIS to develop land suitability for agriculture: Application to durum wheat cultivation in the region of Mleta in Algeria. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 83,117-126. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compag.2012.02.003
  18. Mendas, A., Mebrek, A. and Mekranfar, Z., 2021. Comparison between two multicriteria methods for assessing land suitability for agriculture: application in the area of Mleta in western part of Algeria. Environment Development Sustainability, 23,9076-9089. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10668-020-01012-5
  19. Mousseau, V., 2003. Implementation of ELECTRE Methods: ELECTRE Software, Course of DESS Decision Computer, LAMSADE, University of Paris Dauphine. 28pp.
  20. Nguyen, T.T., Verdoodt, A., Tran, V.Y., Delbecque, N., Tran, T.C. and Van Ranst,, 2015. Design of a GIS and multi-criteria based land evaluation procedure for sustainable land-use planning at the regional level. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 200, pp.1-11. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2014.10.015
  21. Saaty, T.H. and Vargas, L.G., 2001. Models, Methods, Concepts and Applications of the Analytic Hierarchy Process. Kluwer Academic, 160p.
  22. Saaty, T.L., 2008. Decision making with the analytic hierarchy process. International Journal of Services Sciences, 1, 83-98. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJSSCI.2008.017590
  23. Seyedmohammadi, J. and Navidi, M.N., 2022. Applying fuzzy inference system and analytic network process based on GIS to determine land suitability potential for agricultural. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 194, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-022-10327-x
  24. Seyedmohammadi, J. and Navidi, M.N., 2025. Identifying Land Limitations Based on Assessing Their Suitability for Oilseed Plants Cultivation in the Country’s Irrigated Plains. Journal of Soil Research, 39(1),19-51. (In Persian with English abstract)

Seyedmohammadi, J., Sarmadian, F., Jafarzadeh, A.A. and McDowell, R.W., 2019. Development of a model using matter element, AHP and GIS techniques to assess the suitability of land for agriculture. Geoderma, 352, pp.80-95.